By James Holmes
Friday, October 3, marked the 107th meeting between Jesuit and Holy Cross in the Great American Rivalry Series game. This contest has been a fixture of Jesuit student life dating back to 1922, and heading into Friday’s game, the Jays led the series 61–43–1. After three straight defeats at the hands of the Tigers, Jesuit entered Tad Gormley Stadium ready to take back the trophy and reestablish themselves as contenders.
Gameday was marked by an enormous outpouring of Blue Jay spirit. Following an exciting rivalry week full of courtyard competitions, students gathered at assembly Friday morning to hear from Lt. Col. Jared Brupbacher ’97, who served 20 years in the U.S. Air Force. His speech lit a fire under the student body, filled with energizing calls such as “Fly, Fight, Win,” “Fight’s On,” and most importantly, “Carpe Noctem” — Seize the Night. Those words echoed through campus until kickoff.
Even the pep rally hit different. With the impressive debut of Jayrate, Jesuit fans headed into City Park already buzzing. By the time the students made it to Tad Gormley Stadium, the Gizzard was overflowing and electric. Students packed the section from top to bottom, armed with face paint, talcum powder, water bottles, and the type of energy that makes the bleachers shake under your feet. It genuinely felt like the entire school was behind the team.
The Jays opened the night on defense and immediately set the tone with a quick three-and-out. The offense took the field and marched down on an impressive opening drive capped off by a three-yard rushing score from senior quarterback Sully Sullivan. Holy Cross responded on their next possession, but the extra point was blocked — a play that kept Jesuit ahead and set the tone for the special teams all night. The Jays extended the lead shortly after with a 40-yard field goal from kicker Ethan Cabos, taking a 10–6 lead into halftime.
The third quarter looked a lot like the first. Sullivan once again forced his way into the end zone for his second rushing touchdown of the night, giving Jesuit a 17–6 advantage. The Tigers answered quickly to cut the margin to 17–12, but the Blue Jay defense continued to deliver stop after stop, bending at times but never breaking.
One of the turning points came in the fourth quarter. With Holy Cross threatening deep in Jesuit territory, sophomore defensive back McKinley Perry jumped a route and picked off a pass inside the red zone to shut down a Tigers scoring attempt. Later, with Holy Cross mounting their final drive, junior linebacker Chase Cooper broke through the line and delivered a clutch sack that swung momentum back in Jesuit’s favor.
The Jays took advantage. In the closing minutes, Jesuit engineered a slow, methodical 11-play, 75-yard drive that drained more than six and a half minutes of clock. The march ended with another Cabos field goal, this one from 22 yards out, pushing the lead to 20–12 and putting the game out of reach. On the other side of the field, Holy Cross’ lone bright spot was their running back, who rushed for 112 yards on 22 carries, but even those yards couldn’t crack Jesuit’s red-zone wall when it mattered most.
When the clock hit zero, the Blue Jays stormed the field. Jesuit never trailed at any point during the game, and the win sent a message to the entire Catholic League: Jesuit football is far from finished. With the victory, the Jays extended the all-time rivalry record to 62–43–1, reclaiming the Golden Football and snapping Holy Cross’ three-game streak.
This year’s rivalry game also honored two standout Blue Jays. Will Berry received the 2025 Great American Rivalry Student-Athlete Award for his 4.62 GPA, three varsity letters, and service through Krewe de Camp. Cole Puneky earned the 2025 Royal Honda Community Service Award for major service projects, Student Council leadership, and his 34 ACT score, all while working part-time and running his own lawn-care business.
This year’s rivalry game was as intense and rewarding as any of the one hundred and six that came before it. It was physical, emotional, loud, and unforgettable. More importantly, it was a reminder of what this rivalry means to the Jesuit community—more than a football game, more than a trophy, but a chance to carry forward a tradition that has shaped generations of Blue Jays.
Originally published in The Blue Jay’s Fall 2025 print edition, issue 99.2.






