By Grant Carroll
Welcome back to a special holiday issue of Grubbin with Grant! This Mardi Gras season, I was hard at work eating. I made sure to make the most out of Carnival season and eat as much king cake as I could. I wrote down every slice I had to ensure a fair and accurate curation of delectable desserts.
Of course, there were some great king cakes I’ve had in the past that I didn’t get the opportunity to eat this year, but they’ll get an honorable mention.
There was one big idea that led to lots of scholarly debate among my friends and family: What counts as a king cake? Nowadays, it seems like they make any food in a circle and call it a king cake. From sushi to boudin to donuts, if it’s not a real cake, should it be allowed to be called a king cake? I think absolutely yes!
The term “king cake” is synonymous with Mardi Gras. Mardi Gras is all about creativity, inclusivity, and having a good time. I believe it’s hypocritical to the whole celebration to exclude items from the king cake umbrella just because they’re savory or don’t include bread. Now, would I put a sushi king cake in the conversation of the best king cakes? Of course not. But I would still call it a king cake.
Here are my rankings, in order from first king cake tasted to last. They were judged based on overall enjoyability.
Bywater Bakery Chantilly Cake — 6.1/10
• Cream is light and not too sweet. Bread is really good. Could use more icing/sugar on top (most was stuck to the top of the box).
Tartine Original — 7/10
• Very valid traditional option. Very moist and a little messy.
Joe’s Donut Cake — 7.7/10
• The donut is a very nice twist. The bread was good, but the icing could be better.
Gambino’s Cream Cheese — 9.5/10
• Amazing bite of moist cake and delicious cream cheese filling. Thinner cake with layers that melt in your mouth. Visually pretty. My parents didn’t really like this one, but they don’t know ball.
Hubig’s Pie King Cake — 6.5/10
• Good icing. Cream cheese tasted good, but it was inconsistently spaced. Bread could’ve tasted better but had great texture.
Rouses Cream Cheese — 3/10
• Not even a cake, just a cinnamon roll-like inside with mid and very inconsistently placed cream cheese. Bottom-of-the-barrel option for a reason.
Laurel Street Bakery Almond — 8/10
Dorignac’s Original — 4/10
Cannata’s Ooey Gooey — 8.4/10
Robert’s Almond Wedding Cake — 7/10
Honorable Mentions: Duong Phuong and Hi-Do Bakery
Originally published in The Blue Jay’s Winter 2026 print edition, issue 99.3.






