



By Stephen Strecker
The first teacher feature of the 2026–2027 school year is Mr. Alex Scalco ’14. Mr. Scalco is not only an English I and English IV Honors teacher but also a former student. I had the opportunity to sit down with Mr. Scalco and ask him about his experiences as a Blue Jay.
As a student, Mr. Scalco’s favorite class was a Theology of C. S. Lewis class taught by Father Fitzgerald and Dr. Reuther (who was Mr. Reuther back then). They would read C. S. Lewis’s books, share their insights, and even make funny voices for the characters. While the class was academically challenging, Mr. Scalco felt that it prepared him more for college than any of his other classes because of all the difficult texts he had to read and understand. Mr. Scalco said that it was the “gold standard” of classes and is what he wants his honors class to resemble.
After Mr. Scalco graduated from Jesuit, he completed his undergraduate studies at Spring Hill College, where he earned a bachelor’s degree in theology and philosophy. He then attended The Catholic University of America and earned a master’s degree in theology. He then taught theology at McGill-Toolen High School in Mobile, Alabama.
He later applied to work at Jesuit High School. They were hiring for English positions, and since Mr. Scalco liked literature, he decided to take the job. With his theology background, English may seem like a strange choice. However, he said that when it came to theology, he was most interested in Scripture, which is literature, and that the skills he was trained in for analyzing Scripture apply well to British literature.
As he prepared to teach British literature, he reread many texts he had read when he went to school and hadn’t touched since. He said, “Teaching British lit has been a discovery of these old stories that I didn’t necessarily appreciate and completely forgot about. I had to deeply study them. It surprised me how I fell in love with these stories, discovering their richness and value. It’s been a gift and a surprise to teach these.” He began to realize that books such as Sir Gawain and the Green Knight had deep meanings that he did not figure out when he was a student. Tying this in with his theological training, he said, “I want to show people that there is something in these stories they reveal about the spiritual life.”
Mr. Scalco enjoys teaching Macbeth because of the assigned roles, and he also enjoys teaching Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. “I love teaching Sir Gawain, a story I still don’t understand. It’s such a mysterious, confusing, and strange story that I am almost studying it with the class. Every time I go back to it, I’m shocked.” His favorite aspect of teaching is when his students surprise him. He said that any teacher would know the feeling when something clicks with a student in an unexpected moment. He remembers how a student told him that he liked poetry after they studied it, despite poetry usually being seen as boring for high school boys. He said that it is inspiring to see students put effort into things and go above and beyond.
Mr. Scalco also had nothing but good things to say about Jesuit’s faith life opportunities. He said that the evangelization department does a great job and that Jesuit offers many unique spiritual resources that influenced him when he was a student. “When I think about Campus Ministry, I think about how much it influenced me as a student. My faith life started here as a student because of Jesuit. It was the catalyst.” He helps lead the junior-level sodality.
One of Mr. Scalco’s favorite hobbies is cooking. He said that the best way to get him off the subject is to start talking to him about food. His favorite style of food changes throughout the year, with rich, stewy food being his favorite in winter and fish, pasta, and grilled meats in the summer. He is currently experimenting with incorporating more Asian ingredients into his food.
Across Mr. Scalco’s interests and hobbies, one common thread stands out: his love of learning and exploration. Perhaps that is the hallmark of a good teacher: someone who never stops being a student, finds joy in discovery, and shares both his knowledge and his enthusiasm with those he teaches.
From his time in khaki to his time in a shirt and tie, Mr. Scalco ’14 has developed his academic understanding of literature and the faith. Striving for excellence and growth has made Mr. Scalco a shining example of what it means to be a Blue Jay.
Originally published in The Blue Jay, issue 100.1, on November 12, 2026. This issue covers the first quarter of the 2026–2027 school year.

