By Grant Carroll
In this edition of Grubbin’ with Grant, I take on a New Orleans favorite: Clancy’s. Opening in the late 1940s, Clancy’s began as a neighborhood po-boy joint. It wasn’t until the late ’80s that it turned into the white-tablecloth establishment that it is today. Located at 6100 Annunciation Street, it has anchored Uptown New Orleans for generations. Now known as a Creole fine-dining institution, Clancy’s specializes in dishes like lemon icebox pie, fried oysters with brie, smoked soft-shell crab, oysters Rockefeller, smoked duck, and Oysters Bedouin. Under longtime owner Brad Hollingsworth, Clancy’s has managed to keep its old-school neighborhood feel while still delivering an elevated dining experience.
My family drove out there to celebrate good grades and eat some great food. As soon as we entered, I loved the vibe. It felt like a very classic Nola family-owned restaurant. Before your reservation, make sure to give yourself a little time to find parking—it’s street parking only. Inside, you can see the age of the building, not in a bad way, though. The floors creak, the rooms are cramped, and they keep it frosty—so definitely bring a jacket.
The service was very attentive. We never went long without seeing our waiter, and he was chill about making changes to our orders. The menu is entirely cursive, which honestly can throw anyone off if you cannot read it. All the options sounded absolutely delicious; it was hard to only pick a few.
We decided on some salads to share and some peppers with a whipped feta sauce. The salads were pretty good—nothing too special—but I did particularly like the bacon bits. They were crispy but still had some meat on them, so you’re not just chewing on burnt ends and grease. I was not a huge fan of the peppers. The feta whip was on the bottom of the plate, making it hard to get a good combo bite, and the peppers never really got smothered in it, which messed up the flavors and spice levels.
For my entrée, I got grilled drum with jumbo lump crab meat. My first impression was how pretty and shiny it looked—then I realized how much butter was on it. I wanted to enjoy it more, but the textures and flavors were totally drowned out by the butter. I would’ve liked the potatoes to be thinner and crisper, but instead they were dense and didn’t have much flavor on the inside.
My family enjoyed their dishes, and I savored the bites I stole from them. I specifically remember my sister’s steak being cooked perfectly, and the plating on the dishes definitely elevated the experience.
Even though I didn’t have the best things to say about my main course, I still enjoyed my visit. The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was right, and the building has that classic Nola charm. Just be ready to spend some money because the food isn’t cheap. I would come back again, but I’d order something different and ask them to go light on the butter—unless you’re into that sort of thing. All in all, Clancy’s is GRUBBIN APPROVED!
Grubbin’ rating: Absolutely grubbin’.
Originally published in The Blue Jay’s Fall 2025 print edition, issue 99.2.





