By Grant Carroll
On this very special edition of The Blue Jay newspaper, I’m giving recent graduate Alex Santos a second chance and trying out Alma Café. Alex is very proud of his Honduran roots and wouldn’t stop bugging me to give Honduran food another try. Alma now has two locations: the original in Uptown New Orleans and a brand-new spot on Carrollton, right where Mr. Ed’s used to be.
The first Alma opened on Magazine Street and quickly became one of New Orleans’ most talked-about brunch spots. The menu blends traditional Honduran dishes — like baleadas, pupusas, and fried plantains — with New Orleans ingredients and brunch culture. The new Carrollton location opened in 2025, giving Chef Araujo a bigger space to serve even more people, and it’s already packed on weekends.
We showed up for Sunday brunch, and the new location was absolutely buzzing. I was honestly surprised we were able to get seated. The vibe was bright and energetic — you could tell right away this was a place people were excited about. For drinks, my dad ordered a latte, and I tried to get the Irish breakfast tea. A couple of minutes later, the waitress came back and told me they were out. I wasn’t mad, since I’ve never even had Irish tea before, but I was a little confused as to why it was still listed on the menu. No big deal — I switched gears and started scanning the food options.
My dad and I decided to split two dishes: one breakfast, one lunch. We went with the breakfast tacos with chorizo and the bistec encebollado with a side of plantains.
The plates that came out were massive — definitely good bang for your buck. The breakfast tacos were stuffed with eggs, cheese, and chorizo, wrapped in warm tortillas, and topped with salsa that packed some punch. The bistec plate was even bigger: sirloin steak served on top of black beans and rice, smothered in caramelized onions, and paired with pupusas on the side. The steak had a deep, savory flavor, and the onions added just the right amount of sweetness. The plantains were golden, soft, and just the right amount of sweet — easily my favorite part of the meal.
The only problem? It was just so much food. I made a good dent, but finishing the plate felt like running a marathon. I ended up boxing most of it to take home, but if I’m being honest, the leftovers didn’t get eaten. Still, the flavors were solid, and I could see why Alex was so insistent about bringing me here. Overall, it was a good brunch. I might go back again someday, but I guess Honduran food just isn’t my jam.
So what’s my verdict? Alma is worth checking out at least once, especially if you want to branch out from the usual brunch routine. The plates are huge, the atmosphere is lively, and there’s real passion behind the food. I might not be converted into a die-hard Honduran food fan like Alex, but I can respect what Alma is doing and the story behind it.
Grubbin’ rating: Somewhat grubbin’.
Originally published in The Blue Jay’s Summer 2025 print edition, issue 99.1.







