

By Stephen Strecker
In the pantheon of legendary American musicians, Elvis Presley is widely recognized as one of the greatest titans of this nation’s musical history. Known as the “King of Rock and Roll,” Elvis’s career spanned from 1953 until his death in 1977. His total record sales are over a billion; he stared in thirty-three movies and holds the Guiness world record for the best-selling solo-artist of all time. However, despite his incredible fame, most Blue Jays don’t know that the King himself once preformed at Jesuit High School’s very own auditorium.
On October 16th, 1954, a young Elvis Presley and his guitarist, Scotty Moore and bassist, Bill Black, performed on the Louisiana Hayride, a popular live radio and TV show broadcast from Shreveport, LA. While older people in the crowd might have been slightly disturbed by Elvis’s blues-country fusion and his wild hip movements, his performance was a hit with the audience. Horace Logan, the producer, noticed Elvis’s potential with younger audiences and signed him to a 52-week regular performance contract for the show.
Back in New Orleans, a radio DJ and concert promoter named Keith Rush decided to bring Elvis down from Shreveport to perform in New Orleans. Since Jesuit High School had completed a state-of-the-art auditorium in 1953, with great sound quality and a seating capacity of 933 people, it was a good location for a young musician’s performance. It was already used for the Philelectic Society’s plays and other live performances. The show was booked for February 4th, 1955.
For the show, Kieth Rush partnered with prominent entertainment promoter, Yankie Barhanovich. Yankie Barhanovich wanted to promote his daughter, a 15-year-old country singer named Martha Ann Barhanovich, whose stage name was Ann Raye, so he had her open for Elvis. In a 2009 interview with Mat Grau ‘68, Ron Drez ‘58, and Coach Dave Moreau, she stated that she was surprised to see how young Elvis was; after listening to one of his songs for the first time, she assumed that he was an older person because of his deep voice.
Tickets were sold for $1 per person, cheap to encourage teens to attend. Elvis would perform two shows in the auditorium, one at 7:30 and another at 9:00. He would be paid $75 for each show, $1.50 for the entire night. The show was heavily promoted on WBOK, one of New Orleans’ top country stations. It would be a brief show as Elvis was only known for two songs at the time, “That’s Alright Mama,” and “Blue Moon of Kentucky.”
Attending the concert was Shirley Fleniken, who came from Baton Rouge with her sister. She knew that Elvis was performing and had heard his record but “didn’t really think much of it.” When Elvis preformed, she said that all the girls “were screaming and jumping up and down, as he sang and shook that left leg.” After the show she and her sister went backstage to meet Elvis. He signed a picture she had of him. Ms. Fleniken waited awhile after, hoping to talk to him again. To pass the time she picked up a sword stage prop and pretended to be sword fighting. Elvis then came on stage and picked up another toy sword and began to play-duel her, making Ms. Shirley Fleniken (most likely) one of the only people to have had a sword fight with Elvis Presley. “It was quite a thrill to kinda hang out backstage, with him running around all over the place being funny,” Ms. Fleniken remarked. She said that Elvis, “had this certain charisma that is hard to explain- it was something you had to experience. There seemed to be electricity in the air.”
With cheap tickets and great promotion, it seems like the show should have been a huge hit. However, when the night ended, Kieth Rush actually lost money and had to pay Elvis out of pocket. Elvis and his band missed their scheduled radio interview, causing them to miss out on a crucial promotional opportunity. At the end of the day, only 54 people showed up to the performance. Kieth Rush became one of the few people to lose money on Elvis Presley.
Despite being a loss for Kieth Rush, the night would create a great connection for Elvis. Ann Raye was very impressed by Elvis and insisted that her father book him for a show in Biloxi. “I knew that night that Elvis was going to be somebody,” she said in the 2009 interview. Her father began to book Elvis in major locations on the Mississippi Gulf Coast, such as the Slavonian Lodge in Biloxi and military bases in the region.
Two days later, Elvis would meet his famous soon-to-be manager, Colonel Tom Parker, who, through aggressive promotional tactics and savvy business moves, would help launch the young star into fame. Before Elvis signed a management deal with the Colonel, he actually asked Yankie Barhanovich to be his manager. Barhanovich turned Elvis down.
Overall, Elvis Presley’s performance at the Jesuit High School Auditorium on February 4th, 1955, is an amazing part of Jesuit High’s vast history that seems to go unnoticed by most Blue Jays. Though his brief performance may have been one of many concerts of an incredible music career, it goes down forever in Jesuit’s past and the hearts of those who were lucky enough to see and meet him.
Note: I would like to thank Coach Moreau and Mr. Linn who gave me the resources I needed to gather great info for this article!
Originally published in The Blue Jay, issue 100.1, on November 12, 2026. This issue covers the first quarter of the 2026–2027 school year.

